lmm@magnesiacarbonbricklmm.com

Technical support and construction service team

Analysis of Causes of Damage to Ladle slide gate system and Practical Improvement Measures

With the promotion and advancement of secondary refining and continuous casting processes, the requirements for precise control of molten steel flow from the ladle to the tundish are increasingly stringent, while the protection and safety of ladle casting are also becoming more rigorous. Advanced ladle sliding gate systems can meet these requirements and are therefore widely used in large steel enterprises. In the slide gate system, the sliding gate is the component that directly controls the molten steel flow. During use, it is in long-term contact with high-temperature molten steel and is subjected to strong thermal shock during repeated use. Therefore, it must possess characteristics such as high strength, high corrosion resistance, good thermal shock resistance, high temperature resistance, and low creep.

Anshan Iron and Steel Group’s No. 3 Steelmaking and Rolling Mill was the first in Anshan Iron and Steel Group to use large ladles. Since its commencement, with the gradual increase in output and the continuous expansion of steel grades, increasingly stringent requirements have been placed on the use of ladle sliding gates. Through careful summarization and analysis of damage phenomena during the use of sliding gates, a series of measures to extend the service life of ladle slide gates have been proposed, effectively improving the reliability and service life of ladle sliding gates.

Part 1. Common Slide Gate Damage Phenomena and Analysis

The ladle sliding gate used in steel rolling mills has a two-layer structure, as shown in Figure 1. Based on field experience, the damage factors during slide gate use can be divided into three main categories: thermal shock damage, thermochemical corrosion, and improper operation.

1.1 Thermal Shock Damage

The slide plate is at a very low temperature before use, but during the casting process, it comes into contact with high-temperature molten steel for a short period of time. This significant temperature difference generates a strong thermal shock to the slide plate body. Tensile stress is generated outside the slide plate’s casting hole. Once this stress exceeds the strength of the slide plate material, radial microcracks will form, as shown in Figure 2. These cracks facilitate the diffusion, accumulation, and penetration of external molten steel, slag, and oxygen, thus exacerbating chemical corrosion.

1.2 Thermochemical Corrosion

During use, the slide plate comes into contact with high-temperature molten steel and slag, resulting in a series of chemical reactions and causing thermochemical corrosion. This type of corrosion easily leads to decreased high-temperature wear resistance of the slide plate’s working surface, surface layer peeling, poor slide plate fit, increased gaps, and consequently, air intake, further oxidation and corrosion. The alternating effects of these processes can, in severe cases, lead to major accidents such as steel leakage from the slide plate. During the use of slide plates, based on the different steel grades and slag compositions, common thermochemical corrosion phenomena can be classified into the following categories:

1.2.1 Chemical Corrosion of Ca-Treated Steel

In the production of aluminum-killed steel and silicon-aluminum-killed steel, to improve the castability of the molten steel, Ca-Al wire and Ca-Si wire are fed into the molten steel during the refining stage for Ca treatment. When producing this type of steel, the erosion area of the slide plate exhibits a distinct “horseshoe” shape. This is mainly because the [Ca] and CaO in the molten steel react with Al₂O₃ and SiO₂ in the slide plate to form low-melting-point compounds. Especially when the slide plate is in the casting state, the molten steel flowing in the slide plate hole easily forms a negative pressure zone as shown in Figure 3. Under the action of the negative pressure zone, Ca vapor reacts directly with the absorbed oxygen to form CaO, which accumulates in this area, thus leading to the “horseshoe” shaped corrosion.

1.2.2 Chemical Erosion of High-Mn Steel

When casting high-Mn steel grades such as pipeline steel, the pore enlargement of the slide gate is severe, reaching a maximum of 5 mm per furnace. Furthermore, the erosion of the slide gate contact surface is also significant, accompanied by surface spalling and intensified cracking. This is due to the following chemical reactions between MnO in the high-manganese steel and Al₂O₃ and SiO₂ in the slide gate:

MnO + SiO₂ → MnO·SiO₂,

MnO + Al₂O₃ → MnO·Al₂O₃,

leading to the decomposition of corundum and zirconium mullite, the main anti-erosion and thermal shock resistant materials in the slide gate, thus exacerbating the erosion by the molten steel and causing abnormal pore enlargement.

1.2.3 Chemical Erosion by Slag

In the later stages of ladle casting, due to the suction effect of the molten steel flow, some steel slag is drawn into the nozzle, causing slag erosion of the slide gate. Its main characteristics are enlarged pores and erosion of the plate surface, as well as the phenomenon of intensified cracking. The composition of steel slag is relatively complex, mainly including CaO, SiO₂, Al₂O₃, MgO, MnO, FeO, Cr₂O₃, CaF₂, etc. Among them, most of the oxides can form low-melting-point compounds with Al₂O₃ and SiO₂ in the slide plate. In addition, FeO, MnO, etc. may react with the carbon raw materials in the slide plate, causing decarburization, making the surface structure of the slide plate loose and leading to damage.

1.3 Operational Factors

Through practical experience, the operational factors that cause damage to the slide plate can be summarized into three categories: slide plate installation, pouring flow control, and oxygen burning at the nozzle.

(1) Improper slide plate installation. When the slide plate is not strictly leveled when installed in the sliding mechanism, it may tilt or the slide plate clamping may be loose, which will generate a large amount of external stress during use, thus leading to the overall damage of the slide plate.

(2) Improper pouring flow control during production. Improper flow control during the casting process can easily lead to peeling, erosion, and steel clamping on the working surface of the slide plate, as shown in Figure 4. A summary of flow control operations in production reveals that the main cause of slide plate damage is excessive or frequent movement of the slide plate. In particular, manual flow control results in more slide plate damage than computer-controlled flow control, indicating that human factors are a significant cause of slide plate damage.

(3) Improper oxygen firing operation. Oxygen firing is necessary at the ladle nozzles during ladle preparation or when the ladle is not flowing downstream. Improper oxygen firing can lead to severe oxygen erosion. Improper oxygen firing operations causing slide plate damage include: blowing oxygen before the slide plate is fully aligned with the flow channel, causing oxygen to directly impact the working surface of the slide plate; blowing oxygen before the guide sand has completely flowed out, making it difficult to boil and resulting in excessively long blowing time; and the oxygen pipe not being parallel to the flow channel, causing oxygen flow to scour the slide plate hole walls, forming enlarged holes, etc. Other improper operational factors include unreasonable ladle turnover time, leading to a drop in the overall temperature of the ladle and a large thermal shock upon reuse; and improper proportioning of the fire putty used in the slide plate, uneven mixing, and the presence of impurities.

The above-mentioned damage mechanisms interact and promote each other during slide plate preparation and use, making it difficult to attribute slide plate damage to a single cause. Therefore, to improve the service life of the slide plate, a comprehensive analysis and systematic solutions are necessary.

Part 2. Improvement Measures

Based on the analysis of slide plate damage mechanisms, a series of measures for skateboard selection, installation, and use were formulated, effectively improving the service life of the slide plates.

(1) Regarding slide plate materials: Aluminum-zirconium carbon skateboards with good corrosion resistance and thermal shock resistance were selected. These skateboards use corundum, mullite, and zircon as the main crystalline phases, with carbonaceous materials as the binder. Therefore, the slide plates have high thermal conductivity, low coefficient of thermal expansion, and fine pores. Moreover, ZrO₂ can undergo a phase transformation at 1000℃, which is beneficial to improving the slide plate’s thermal shock resistance.

(2) Regarding the slide plate mechanism: A horseshoe-shaped clamping structure was selected to ensure uniform stress distribution and avoid the stress concentration defects that are prone to occur in simple geometric shapes. An eccentric wheel device was used in conjunction with the locking slide plate to apply a uniform locking load, making it easy for operators to control the locking torque. The upper and lower slide plates were fitted with a spring-loaded thrust frame structure to ensure good contact between the slide plate surfaces and appropriate gaps.

(3) Regarding slide plate installation: Ensure the slide plate mortar mix is correctly proportioned, evenly mixed, and free of foreign impurities; it is strictly forbidden to use dried, lumpy mortar, and it is strictly forbidden to mix used mortar with new mortar. During slide plate installation, ensure the inlet is thoroughly cleaned, and the inside of the slide plate frame and mechanism doors are strictly cleaned, with no residue. Before installation, carefully inspect the mechanism and slide plate to ensure the horseshoe and eccentric wheel move normally, and that the slide plate is free from deformation or cracking. Also, check the flatness of the slide plate surface. Place the slide plate stably, and after installation, check for unevenness or swaying.

(4) Regarding slide plate usage: During the pouring process, use an automatic pouring program as much as possible, avoiding manual large-scale opening and closing of the slide plate, as well as excessively frequent opening and closing. If oxygen is required, ensure the slide plate is fully open, the drainage sand is discharged as much as possible, and the oxygen pipe is as parallel as possible to the molten steel channel.

(5) Regarding ladle preparation: When cleaning the ladle inlet, except for replacing the inlet, it is strictly forbidden to blow oxygen from inside the ladle for cleaning. Oxygen cleaning should be performed as quickly as possible. After preparation, the sliding plate drive mechanism should be moved to check if the working surface of the sliding plate is normal. If any abnormality is found, the sliding plate should be replaced immediately. In addition, reasonable production organization and ensuring ladle turnover are also important measures to improve the lifespan of the sliding plate. If the ladle has been left to cool for too long, the sliding plate must be replaced to prevent accidents.

By taking the above measures, not only was the lifespan of the sliding plate improved, but the annual consumption of sliding plates was reduced by 700 sets, effectively reducing the cost of refractory materials. Furthermore, no steel leakage accidents caused by sliding plate damage occurred, significantly improving safety.

Part 3. Conclusion

With the development of rapid and efficient smelting-continuous casting technology, very stringent requirements have been placed on the material and practical performance of the sliding plate. Based on extensive practical experience summarizing slide plate damage phenomena, the following conclusions were drawn:

1) Thermal shock damage, thermochemical corrosion, and improper operation are the three main causes of slide plate damage;

2) Thermal shock damage is primarily caused by drastic temperature fluctuations in the working area of the slide plate during ladle turnover;

3) The composition of modern high-value-added steel grades and the processes used in molten steel treatment easily lead to thermochemical corrosion of the slide plate;

4) Operational factors during the installation, use, and maintenance of the slide plate are significant external causes of slide plate damage.

Based on these conclusions, targeted measures to extend the lifespan of slide plates are proposed:

1) Using aluminum-zirconium carbon slide gate plates to ensure good corrosion resistance and thermal shock resistance;

2) Using a rationally designed slide gate plate shape and mechanism with uniform stress distribution is an effective measure to improve the service life of the slide plate;

3) Standardizing molten steel pouring operations is a necessary guarantee for improving the service life of the slide plate;

4) Correct and proper cleaning and maintenance of the slide plate and its sliding mechanism are also crucial for extending the lifespan of the slide gate plate.

LMM YOTAI established in 2007. Our production technology comes from Japanese Yotai. As an experienced and international player in the refractories industry. We have succeeded in expanding both the breadth of its product range and the depth of its services. From raw material selection, refractory portofio & optimization, installation & services & recycle of used refractories on site to further reduce client’s Opex & Capex in refractory consumption per ton steel output, meanwhile improve product quality of client.

Our Product have been supplied to world’s top steel manufacturer Arcelormittal, TATA Steel, EZZ steel etc. We do OEM for Concast and Danieli for a long time

Facebook
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Comprehensive solution of Refractory for steelmaking

Fill out the form below, and we will be in touch shortly.
Contact Information