lmm@magnesiacarbonbricklmm.com

Technical support and construction service team

Permanent lining of ladle for stainless steel production using zero carbon tempered MgO-ZnO bricks instead of fired magnesia chrome bricks

New environmentally friendly processes and reduced pollutant emissions are the new driving force in the steelmaking industry. Magnesia chrome bricks fired above 1700℃ are used for permanent lining of ladle for stainless steel production due to their high physical and mechanical properties and dimensional stability. Tempered refractory bricks use a special binder that eliminates the process of burning fossil fuels and there is no carbon dioxide emission from the combustion process. The new refractory bricks are based on MgO-ZnO with free chromium and carbon. This article describes the properties and results of sintered and tempered bricks used for safe refractory lining of stainless steel production ladles.

Stainless steel was first introduced in 1912-1913 and is an important class of corrosion-resistant alloys. It is used in different applications, from cookware and furniture to very complex buildings and space vehicles. Although stainless steel has a higher cost compared to carbon steel, it has other beneficial properties that can save costs in terms of durability, high temperature performance, ductility, impact resistance, reusability and recyclability.

Stainless steel is available in various grades with different properties. Five major categories are classified according to their metallurgical composition: austenitic stainless steel, ferritic stainless steel, duplex stainless steel (austenite-ferrite), martensitic stainless steel and precipitation hardening stainless steel. These stainless steel materials contain at least 10.5% chromium, which is responsible for their corrosion resistance, since chromium reacts with oxygen and forms a film on the surface of the material that prevents further oxidation. In this type of stainless steel, in addition to the required chromium content, some alloying elements such as nickel, manganese, copper, molybdenum, silicon, nitrogen and phosphorus can be added.

During the secondary metallurgical refining of stainless steel, the molten steel is fed into ladles for transportation and alloying. Ladles are made of different refractory grades, depending on the erosion mechanisms present during operation. In this case, the common state of the ladles for the production of stainless steel is to use calcined dolomite refractory bricks in the working lining and magnesia-chrome bricks in the permanent lining.

The two main components of calcined dolomite bricks are CaO and MgO, and this type of refractory material is often used in silicon-killed steel production due to its high compatibility with basic slag and low cost. Direct bonded calcined dolomite bricks are fired at high temperatures in tunnel kilns until a ceramic bond is formed. Although the presence of CaO makes the brick hydration sensitive, it plays a crucial role in the chemical behavior of the material. The slag resistance of calcined dolomite bricks is due to free lime, which is able to form a dense Ca2SiO4 (C2S) layer with high refractoriness (2154℃) and protect the material from further penetration and erosion by slag.

Different types of stainless steel are produced in the same ladle, which makes the process have a wide range of adaptability requirements for refractory materials. Due to the high chromium content of this stainless steel type, magnesia-chrome bricks are often used for safe permanent lining of stainless steel ladles as it is compatible with the process. These bricks are known for their ability to form a ceramic bond during sintering due to secondary spinel formation, which is responsible for high mechanical properties, corrosion resistance, erosion and thermal stability.

The presence of “complex spinel”, (Mg,Fe, [Cr,Al, Fe]2O4) in the microstructure plays an important role in the thermodynamic properties of MgO-Cr2O3 refractory bricks. Secondary spinels help to form direct bonds between grains and prevent slag attack. They may be formed by precipitation of spinel-rich silicate liquid phase or precipitation during cooling of solid solution. Intergranular spinels form within the MgO grain boundaries, and intragranular spinels form within the MgO grain boundaries.

Magnesium-chrome refractory bricks are divided into direct bond type, rebound type, semi-rebound type, and a new type of tempered zero-carbon material has been developed in recent years. Regardless of the production process, all grades have a high chromium content. Therefore, under normal industrial temperature and oxidizing conditions (in air), the trivalent chromium (Cr3+) present in MgO-Cr2O3 refractory can be oxidized to Cr6+. The formation of hexavalent chromium is catalyzed by an alkaline environment, slow cooling rates, small crystals, the presence of CaF2 and low temperatures. This component is soluble in water and is known to be carcinogenic. Due to stricter environmental regulations, the steelmaking industry is aware of this problem and has therefore made great efforts to recycle and reduce solid emission waste.

Steelmaking consumes a lot of refractory materials, and most of the refractory materials commonly used in ladles in stainless steel production are fired at high temperatures, which will release a lot of carbon dioxide. In order to reduce the emission of pollutants, a new environmentally friendly refractory brick binder system with zero carbon content has been developed as an alternative to the current fired refractory materials.

In this case, zero carbon tempered MgO-ZnO refractory bricks were developed as an alternative solution for the permanent lining of ladles in stainless steel production. Due to its rapid sintering ability, this new material is able to develop ideal properties while using the energy already present in the process, allowing the refractory bricks to be delivered to customers in a tempered condition of 200°C. The new refractory bricks do not contain chromium, are easier to recycle, and have less carbon dioxide emissions due to the elimination of the firing process and shorter delivery time. This article introduces the performance comparison and user application results of calcined MgO-Cr2O3 refractory bricks and tempered MgO-ZnO refractory bricks.

Test procedure

The safety lining of customer A’s stainless steel ladle uses a commercial brand of semi-resilient MgO-Cr2O3 refractory bricks. The MgO-Cr2O3 bricks are fired at 1730℃ and the MgO-ZnO is tempered at 200℃. The composition of the two materials is shown in Table 1.

Table 1 Composition of MgO-Cr2O3 refractory bricks fired at 1730℃ and tempered at 200℃

stainless steel

The sample specimens were received from the factory after firing at 1400°C/5 hours. The heat treatment was carried out in an electric furnace. The heating rate was 215°C/hour, and it was heated to 1170°C, after which the heating data was maintained at 41°C/hour to 1400°C. The bulk density and apparent porosity were evaluated using the Archimedes principle and liquid immersion method according to ASTM C20 standard. The dimensions of the refractory bricks before and after firing were measured using a digital caliper to measure the permanent volume expansion (PVE). The cold compressive strength (CCS) test was performed on the sample specimens of 50x50x50mm3 using a 100 kN load cell (JIS R 2206 5013) in Kratos ECC, and the elastic modulus was measured using an ultrasonic device (James Instruments – Model C-4902 “V” meter, 150 kHz) according to ASTM C885.9.

Mercury porosimetry was performed using an AutoPore V9605 device according to ISO 15901-1, allowing the evaluation of the average pore size after 1400 °C/5 h. Crystalline phases were identified using X-ray diffraction (XRD) techniques using X’Pert PRO (40 mA, 40 kV). Thermodynamic simulations using FactSage (equilibrium model) predicted the phases of the MgO-ZnO system in equilibrium.

After heat treatment at 1000 °C/5 h, corrosion tests on octagonal prisms were performed in an induction furnace at 1700 °C/3 h to eliminate all volatile substances of the tempered bricks. The specimens were immersed in steel containing synthetic slag, which was changed every 30 min to avoid saturation. After the induction corrosion tests, microstructural analysis was performed using an optical microscope (Carl Zeiss – mode: AXIO-Imager. A1m).

Discussion

Thermomechanical properties

The mechanical and physical properties of both materials are shown in Table 2.

Table 2 Thermodynamic properties of MgO-Cr2O3 and MgO-ZnO after 1400℃/5h

stainless steel

(Characteristics: density, apparent porosity, cold damage strength, elastic modulus; density, apparent porosity, permanent deformation volume, cold damage strength, elastic modulus, pore size D50)

As MgO-Cr2O3 enters the firing process at high temperature (1730℃) in the tunnel kiln, there is direct bonding between the grains and its microstructure has been formed. The sintering process is the reason for its higher bulk density and apparent porosity. In this case, the larger the pore volume, the lower the CCS compared to tempered MgO-ZnO.

After heat treatment at 1400℃/5 hours, the bulk density, apparent porosity, CCS, elastic modulus of the material increase slightly, and the material shows permanent volume expansion. Even if the refractory brick has been fired at 1730℃, SiO2 in the chromite will migrate into the matrix, thus changing the properties of the brick. The crystalline phase shown by XRD analysis (Figure 1) is common to magnesia-chrome bricks. Chromite and the secondary spinel formed after heat treatment contain MgO, spinel chromite, and auxiliary phases such as forsterite and olivine.

stainless steel

Figure 1  X-ray diffraction of magnesia-chrome bricks

MgO-ZnO is delivered to the customer after tempering at 200°C, so after 1400°C/5 hours, its bulk density decreases and apparent porosity increases as volatile compounds are eliminated and the sintering process begins. In this case, sintering results in higher CCS and elastic modulus. As shown in Figure 2, zinc can form a solid solution with magnesium, which is why no ZnO crystal phase is found in the XRD analysis (Figure 3). Zinc oxide has been reported as a densification additive in magnesia-alumina spinel systems due to its fast diffusion rate. It should enter the spinel structure and create anion vacancies in it, thus facilitating the densification process.

Figure 2 Thermodynamic simulation of phases in tempered MgO-ZnO bricks

stainless steel

Figure 3 X-ray diffraction of MgO-ZnO bricks

It can be observed that tempered MgO-ZnO has faster sintering performance, which is due to the reactivity of the new binder system enabling the formation of its microstructure. In addition, the tempered composition has a smaller pore size (D50), as shown in Table 2. In this case, the sintering efficiency and uniform distribution of small pores lead to higher mechanical strength and equal corrosion resistance, as shown in Table 3. After induction corrosion testing on the slag line, the microstructures of both materials are shown in Figures 4 and 5, and it can be observed that there is slag adhesion in both materials without slag penetration. Although ZnO has not been reported in alkaline systems, it contributes to the effectiveness of the sintering process.

Table 3  Induction corrosion tests of MgO-Cr2O3 and MgO-ZnO after heat treatment at 1000℃/5 hours

stainless steel

Figure 4  Sample specimens of MgO-Cr2O3 and MgO-ZnO bricks after induction corrosion test

stainless steel

Figure 5 Microstructure after MgO-Cr2O3 and MgO-ZnO induction corrosion tests

Customer trials

Several tests were conducted for the safety lining of a stainless steel ladle for customer A. Both refractory bricks were always assembled and used in the same ladle. The following sections will highlight some of the test results. Test A: 93 MgO-ZnO tempered bricks (230×65×70 mm) were assembled and masonry in the same equipment ladle container as the fired MgO-Cr2O3 refractory bricks to ensure the same operating conditions. The assembly is shown in Figure 6. During the entire production process, a total of 8 different grades of stainless steel were produced, which ended in 42 furnaces due to erosion of the calcined dolomite refractory bricks used. After the test, no abnormalities were found in the MgO-ZnO bricks.

Figure 6  Assembly and masonry of sintered MgO-Cr2O3 and tempered MgO-ZnO in the same ladle

Test B: 300 pieces of MgO-ZnO tempered bricks (230×65×70 mm) were assembled and masonry on the same ladle as the fired MgO-Cr2O3 bricks to ensure the same operating conditions. The assembly is shown in Figure 7. During the production process, four different grades of stainless steel were produced, and the production ended after 30 furnaces due to the erosion of the calcined dolomite bricks used in the slag working lining. The MgO-ZnO bricks used for the safe permanent lining were removed and inspected, and the appearance was good after sintering, as shown in Figure 8.

Figure 7 Sintered MgO-Cr2O3 and tempered MgO-ZnO are assembled in the same ladle

Figure 8  Fired MgO-Cr2O3 and tempered MgO-ZnO refractory bricks after demolition

Conclusion

The tempered bricks after heat treatment show good properties due to the presence of binder system and zinc oxide, which diffuses into magnesium oxide to form a solid solution. The combination of zero carbon binder and zinc oxide improves the efficiency of the sintering process. Using a unique zero carbon, zero chromium binder system, tempered magnesia bricks for stainless steel safety linings have been developed. The new development is an environmentally friendly alternative for stainless steel ladle safety linings. The customer trials presented in this article have shown very good results and new trials are underway to consolidate the technology.

LMM YOTAI established in 2007. Our production technology comes from Japanese Yotai. As an experienced and international player in the refractories industry. We have succeeded in expanding both the breadth of its product range and the depth of its services. From raw material selection, refractory portofio & optimization, installation & services & recycle of used refractories on site to further reduce client’s Opex & Capex in refractory consumption per ton steel output, meanwhile improve product quality of client.

Our Product have been supplied to world’s top steel manufacturer Arcelormittal, TATA Steel, EZZ steel etc. We do OEM for Concast and Danieli for a long time

Facebook
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Comprehensive solution of Refractory for steelmaking

Fill out the form below, and we will be in touch shortly.
Contact Information