lmm@magnesiacarbonbricklmm.com

Technical support and construction service team

VOD Stainless Steelmaking Process: Electric Arc Furnace Duplex Method for Ultra-Low Carbon Stainless Steel

Producing ultra-low carbon stainless steel by the conventional VOD stainless steelmaking process typically involves multiple alloy adjustment and ladle transfer operations before vacuum refining. In many steel plants, molten steel from an electric arc furnace (EAF) is first refined in a ladle furnace (LF), where chromium, manganese, and silicon are adjusted before being transferred to another ladle for Vacuum Oxygen Decarburization (VOD). Another common practice is to partially adjust alloy composition in the EAF and complete the remaining alloy additions during LF refining prior to VOD treatment. Although both methods are widely used, they require relatively complex process routes and extended refining times.

To improve production efficiency, the company implemented a duplex steelmaking route in which two electric arc furnaces performed separate tasks before the molten steel entered the VOD refining stage. One furnace produced low-phosphorus oxidized molten steel, while the other was dedicated to melting alloy materials. After combining the two heats, only minor composition adjustments were required before vacuum treatment. This Electric Arc Furnace–VOD duplex process simplified the refining procedure, shortened the production cycle, and significantly improved alloy utilization while maintaining the quality requirements for ultra-low carbon stainless steel.

The process was verified during the production of approximately 70 tonnes of Z3CN20-09M stainless steel. The following sections describe the equipment configuration, operating procedures, and production results obtained during the industrial trial.

Equipment Configuration

The VOD refining facility used in this study was reconstructed from an existing 130 t VD ladle refining unit. The vacuum cover was redesigned and equipped with a Laval-type water-cooled oxygen lance, a furnace gas temperature monitoring system, and a micro-oxygen analyzer to provide reliable carbon endpoint control during the Vacuum Oxygen Decarburization process.

An electronic video monitoring system was also installed on the vacuum cover, allowing operators to continuously observe furnace reactions and splashing behavior throughout oxygen blowing.

Two 500 kg vacuum charging hoppers were provided for the addition of slag-forming materials and deoxidizing alloys after VOD treatment. Vacuum generation was supplied by a four-stage steam ejector system capable of maintaining a vacuum level below 133 Pa, meeting the operational requirements of the duplex stainless steelmaking process.

The primary melting equipment consisted of:

  • One 40 t EBT Electric Arc Furnace (EBT EAF) for producing low-phosphorus oxidized molten steel.
  • One 30 t Electric Arc Furnace (EAF) dedicated to alloy melting.
  • A Ladle Furnace (LF) for alloy adjustment and temperature control.
  • A VOD refining station for decarburization and final refining.

Process Flow of the Electric Arc Furnace–VOD Duplex Method

The industrial trial was carried out using Z3CN20-09M stainless steel with a total heat size of approximately 70 t. The target chemical composition and the requirements for primary molten steel are shown in Table 1.

Unlike the conventional refining route, the duplex process assigned separate functions to the two electric arc furnaces. The 40 t EBT furnace produced low-phosphorus oxidized molten steel without adjusting alloy composition, while the 30 t electric arc furnace was used exclusively for melting the required ferroalloys.

After both heats were completed, the alloy melt was transferred together with its slag into the ladle furnace to maximize chromium recovery. The oxidized molten steel from the 40 t EBT furnace was then tapped into the same ladle using strict slag retention practices to minimize phosphorus reversion. Following minor composition adjustment, the combined molten steel was transferred to another ladle with additional slag retention before entering the VOD stainless steelmaking process.

After vacuum oxygen decarburization, only minor alloy trimming and temperature adjustment were required before continuous casting.

Table 1 The main chemical composition of Z3CN20-09M steel(mass fraction,%)

CSiMnPSCrNi
Standard requirements≤0.04≤1.50≤1.50≤0.030≤0.01519.00~21.008.00~11.00
Electric furnace roughing40 t(EBT)≤0.03__≤0.003___

30 t(EAF)
0.70~0.90____50.00~53.0022.00~24.00
VOD refinementBefore dumping0.30~0.40≤0.50≤0.30≤0.020≤0.02019.50~20.008.00~8.50
Process flow diagram of the electric arc furnace–VOD duplex stainless steelmaking process for Z3CN20-09M ultra-low carbon stainless steel.
Figure 1. Process flow of the electric arc furnace–VOD duplex method used for producing Z3CN20-09M stainless steel.

30 t Electric Arc Furnace Smelting Practice

Charge Materials

The primary function of the 30 t electric arc furnace was to melt the ferroalloys required for the final stainless steel composition. Because carbon oxidation was intentionally avoided during alloy melting, medium-carbon and low-carbon ferrochrome were selected as the principal chromium-bearing materials.

The charging practice adopted during the industrial trial is summarized in Table 2.

Table 2. Charging Materials for the 30 t Electric Arc Furnace

Low chromium/tMedium chromium/t Nickel plate/t  Total ingredients/t Amount of C (mass fraction, %)
6165.827.80.56

Operating Procedures

During alloy melting, chromium and nickel contents were adjusted directly according to the target composition of the finished stainless steel. Since no carbon steel was charged during the operation, chemical analysis mainly focused on monitoring the carbon content throughout the melting period.

The slag volume was maintained at approximately 5% of the molten steel weight, while the lime-to-fluorspar ratio was controlled at approximately 4:1. Carbon pickup was minimized throughout melting, and limited oxygen blowing was applied when necessary to assist furnace operation without significantly increasing oxidation losses.

After complete melting, ferrosilicon powder was added in several small batches to reduce chromium oxide in the slag and improve chromium recovery. Chemical compositions measured immediately after melting and before tapping are presented in Table 3.

Table 3. Chemical Composition After Melting and Before Tapping in the 30 t Electric Arc Furnace(mass fraction,%)

CSiMnPSCrNi
After melting0.790.530.420.0160.00550.1321.93
Before tapping
0.79

0.72

0.43

0.015

0.005

49.68

21.08

40 t EBT Electric Arc Furnace Smelting Practice

Charge Materials

The charging practice for the 40 t EBT Electric Arc Furnace is presented in Table 4. Unlike the 30 t furnace, which was dedicated to alloy melting, the primary objective of the 40 t EBT furnace was to produce low-phosphorus oxidized molten steel suitable for subsequent LF and VOD refining.

Table 4. Charging Materials for the 40 t EBT Electric Arc Furnace

Pig iron/tHigh-quality scrap steel/tTotal batching amount/t Amount of blending C (mass fraction, %)
7.240.8480.60

Operating Procedures

The 40 t EBT Electric Arc Furnace supplied low-phosphorus primary molten steel for the subsequent refining process. Successful operation depended on establishing a highly oxidizing slag with sufficient basicity while maintaining an appropriate steel temperature to promote rapid dephosphorization.

During melting, carbon and phosphorus contents were reduced as much as possible while ensuring adequate decarburization. The target tapping conditions were as follows:

  • Phosphorus ≤ 0.003%
  • Carbon ≤ 0.03%
  • Molten steel temperature ≥ 1660°C

Once these requirements were achieved, tapping was carried out using an electronic ladle weighing system while applying strict slag retention practices. Slag carryover was carefully controlled both during tapping and during molten steel transfer in order to minimize phosphorus reversion before refining.

The chemical composition before tapping is shown in Table 5.

Table 5. Chemical Composition Before Tapping from the 40 t EBT Electric Arc Furnace

CPMoCrNi
0.030.0020.330.040.02

LF and VOD Refining Operations

Preparation Before Ladle Transfer

Two refining ladles were prepared before refining operations. The ladle used for LF treatment was lined with magnesia-carbon bricks, while the ladle designated for VOD refining was lined with magnesia-chrome bricks. Both ladles were preheated to temperatures above 800°C before receiving molten steel.

The alloy melt produced in the 30 t Electric Arc Furnace was first transferred into the LF ladle together with its slag to maximize chromium recovery. The low-phosphorus molten steel from the 40 t EBT furnace was then added while maintaining strict slag retention practices to minimize phosphorus pickup.

After the two molten steel streams were combined, reducing slag was formed and electric heating was applied. Following sampling and minor alloy adjustment, the chemical composition was brought into specification according to the target values shown previously in Table 1.

Before ladle transfer, the molten steel temperature was increased to above 1680°C. The steel was then transferred into the VOD ladle using strict slag retention before vacuum refining commenced.

The chemical composition after combining the two heats is shown in Table 6.

Table 6. Chemical Composition After Combining the Two Molten Steel Heats

CSiMnPSCrNiMoNCu
0.320.080.20.0140.01418.257.150.210.03490.05

VOD Refining Procedure

The operational sequence of the VOD refining stage is illustrated in Figure 2. Oxygen blowing was first performed under vacuum conditions to promote decarburization. After oxygen blowing, slag composition was adjusted while maintaining the vacuum environment.

Following slag adjustment, the vacuum level was further reduced to below 133 Pa. Vacuum degassing (VD) treatment was then maintained for approximately 15–20 minutes to complete refining.

After vacuum treatment, minor alloy additions were made to compensate for composition changes during decarburization. Once the required steel temperature and chemical composition had been achieved, the heat was released for casting.

Operational flow chart of the Vacuum Oxygen Decarburization refining process during duplex stainless steel production.
Figure 2. Operational sequence of the VOD refining stage for ultra-low carbon stainless steel production.

Key Process Parameters

The principal operating parameters recorded during VOD refining are summarized in Table 7.

Table 7. Main Operating Parameters During the VOD Refining Process

Process parametersParameter value
Refining container capacity/t130
Liquid steel volume/t70
Free space height inside bag/mm1380
Oxygen gun stroke/m1.2
Oxygen pressure/MPa0.8
Nitrogen flow/L·min-170~80
Oxygen blowing time/min32
Maximum instantaneous flow rate of oxygen/m³·h-1990
Total oxygen consumption/m³589.2
Vacuum degree/Pa during VOD oxygen blowing1333.2~1999.8

The changes in chemical composition before and after VOD refining are presented in Table 8, demonstrating that the duplex process successfully achieved the composition required for Z3CN20-09M ultra-low carbon stainless steel.

Table 8. Chemical Composition Before and After VOD Refining

CSiMnPS CrNiMo
Before VOD0.320.080.220.0150.01119.38.520.24
After VOD0.0170.160.190.0140.0119.028.50.24

Discussion

The industrial trial demonstrated that the Electric Arc Furnace–VOD duplex method is a practical solution for producing ultra-low carbon stainless steel. Compared with the conventional VOD stainless steelmaking process, separating the responsibilities of the two electric arc furnaces simplified primary melting and significantly improved overall production efficiency. The successful trial of Z3CN20-09M stainless steel also provided the company with an effective process route for future stainless steel production.

Reduced Smelting Time

Production records showed that the duplex process substantially shortened the overall steelmaking cycle.

Under the conventional process, the primary molten steel produced in the electric arc furnace required partial chromium adjustment, dephosphorization, reduction refining, and additional alloy correction before entering VOD treatment. As a result, the electric arc furnace generally required approximately 4–5 hours to complete one heat, while the subsequent ladle refining stage also required considerable time because of the large quantity of alloy additions.

In the duplex process, the responsibilities of the two electric arc furnaces were clearly separated. The 30 t furnace was dedicated exclusively to alloy melting. Since no dephosphorization or extensive chemical adjustment was required, tapping could be performed as soon as the alloys were completely melted and the desired temperature had been reached. The melting cycle was generally reduced to approximately 2–2.5 hours.

Meanwhile, the 40 t EBT Electric Arc Furnace focused solely on producing low-phosphorus oxidized molten steel. Because alloy additions were not required during primary melting, furnace operation was simplified, and the smelting period was generally completed within 2.5–3 hours.

After the two molten steel streams were combined, only minor composition adjustment and temperature correction were necessary before entering the VOD refining stage. Consequently, the overall steelmaking cycle was reduced to approximately 3–4 hours, compared with the conventional production time of 5–7 hours.

Higher Chromium Recovery

Chromium recovery was also significantly improved through the duplex steelmaking route.

In the conventional process, part of the chromium-bearing alloy was added directly into the electric arc furnace during primary melting. Because of oxidation losses during refining, the chromium recovery rate was typically around 90%.

Under the duplex process, all alloy materials were melted in the dedicated 30 t electric arc furnace and transferred into the ladle together with the furnace slag. This operating practice made it possible to recover chromium contained in the slag during subsequent reducing slag treatment. As a result, chromium recovery increased to approximately 97–99%, improving alloy utilization and reducing raw material consumption.

Potential for Further Process Simplification

To ensure stable operation during the industrial trial, molten steel was transferred into a second ladle before VOD treatment. However, production observations indicated that the combined molten steel had already reached the required chemical composition and temperature after LF adjustment.

Therefore, the ladle transfer operation could potentially be eliminated in future production. Removing this step would further simplify the refining procedure, shorten production time, reduce heat losses, and lower overall steelmaking costs while maintaining the quality requirements of the finished stainless steel.

Conclusion

The successful production trial of Z3CN20-09M stainless steel demonstrated that melting the required ferroalloys separately and combining them with low-phosphorus primary molten steel before VOD refining is a practical and reliable steelmaking route.

The Electric Arc Furnace–VOD duplex process not only satisfied the quality requirements for ultra-low carbon stainless steel but also significantly improved production efficiency. Compared with the conventional refining route, the optimized process shortened the steelmaking cycle, increased chromium recovery, simplified alloy adjustment, and reduced overall production costs.

The industrial results indicate that this duplex steelmaking process provides an effective approach for improving stainless steel production efficiency while maintaining stable metallurgical performance, making it suitable for further application and optimization in industrial stainless steel manufacturing.

The successful industrial trial demonstrates that the duplex electric arc furnace–VOD route provides an efficient and practical solution for producing ultra-low carbon stainless steel while improving productivity and alloy recovery.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the VOD stainless steelmaking process?

In this study, the VOD stainless steelmaking process refers to the vacuum refining stage following the duplex electric arc furnace operation. Oxygen is blown under vacuum conditions to achieve ultra-low carbon levels while maintaining chromium recovery.

Why does the duplex process reduce steelmaking time?

By assigning separate responsibilities to two electric arc furnaces, alloy melting and low-phosphorus molten steel production can be completed simultaneously. This significantly reduces the workload during ladle refining and shortens the overall production cycle.

How does the duplex process improve chromium recovery?

Alloy materials are melted separately and transferred together with the slag into the refining ladle, allowing chromium contained in the slag to be recovered during reducing slag treatment. Industrial results showed chromium recovery increased from approximately 90% to 97–99%.

Why is low-phosphorus molten steel required before VOD refining?

Maintaining a very low phosphorus level before vacuum refining minimizes phosphorus reversion during subsequent operations and helps ensure the final stainless steel meets stringent quality requirements.

What vacuum level was used during the VOD process?

According to the production trial, the vacuum system maintained a pressure below 133 Pa, followed by approximately 15–20 minutes of vacuum degassing before final alloy adjustment.

Can the ladle transfer step be eliminated?

The production trial suggested that, after combining the two molten steel streams and completing LF adjustment, the molten steel had already reached the required composition and temperature. Therefore, eliminating the additional ladle transfer step may further simplify production in future applications.

What type of stainless steel was produced during the industrial trial?

The duplex process was successfully applied to the production of approximately 70 tonnes of Z3CN20-09M ultra-low carbon stainless steel.

What are the primary advantages of the Electric Arc Furnace–VOD duplex process?

The main benefits include a shorter production cycle, higher chromium recovery, simplified alloy adjustment, improved refining efficiency, and lower overall steelmaking costs while maintaining product quality.

LMM YOTAI established in 2007. Our production technology comes from Japanese Yotai. As an experienced and international player in the refractories industry. We have succeeded in expanding both the breadth of its product range and the depth of its services. From raw material selection, refractory portofio & optimization, installation & services & recycle of used refractories on site to further reduce client’s Opex & Capex in refractory consumption per ton steel output, meanwhile improve product quality of client.

Our Product have been supplied to world’s top steel manufacturer Arcelormittal, TATA Steel, EZZ steel etc. We do OEM for Concast and Danieli for a long time

Facebook
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Comprehensive solution of Refractory for steelmaking

Fill out the form below, and we will be in touch shortly.
Contact Information